Austin W. Duncan

View Original

What is sin?

See this content in the original post

Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio

What is sin? Austin W. Duncan | Word for Word, ep. 5 | Basic Christian Thought and Spiritual Growth

What is sin?

Buddhists call it suffering. Philosophers call it the human condition. Psychologists call it the shadow of self. Every culture, every religion, every civilization has recognized this universal human problem - this fundamental flaw in our nature. But thousands of years ago, the Bible gave it a simpler name: sin. Now, before you tune out thinking this is just another person teaching about breaking rules or feeling guilty, let me tell you why this three-letter word might completely change how you see yourself, your world, and why everything seems so…broken.

The Aspects of Sin

Let’s start with what sin isn’t. Sin isn’t primarily about breaking rules. It’s not just about doing bad things. And it’s definitely not about God being a killjoy in an effort to stop us from having fun. It’s the root of humanity’s broken relationship with God, others, and even creation. For example, to understand salvation, faith, and restoration, we must first grasp what sin really is and why its consequences run so deep.

Throughout the Bible, we see different facets of sin that help us understand its full nature and effects. Think of it like looking at a diamond - each angle reveals something new about its character. Let’s break down these aspects:

Sin is Transgression (Breaking God’s Law)

First, sin is transgression - an active breaking of God's law. The apostle John puts it plainly:

This isn't just about failing to meet a standard; it's about crossing a line that God has drawn. When God says "You shall not," and we say "I will," that's transgression. It's like a child whose parent draws a line in the sand and says "don't cross this" - and the child looks them in the eye while stepping over it. It's not just failure; it's defiance. Think about a child whose parent draws a line in the sand and says "don't cross this." When the child steps over that line while looking their parent in the eye, they're doing more than just moving their foot to a different spot in the sand. They're making a statement about authority. They're saying, "I know you said not to, but I don't accept your right to set that boundary."

We see this pattern established in the very first sin. In Genesis 3, Eve knew God's command not to eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil. The serpent didn't just trick her about what God had said - instead, he questioned God's motives and authority: "Did God actually say...?" When Eve took the fruit, she wasn't accidentally stumbling into sin. She was deliberately stepping across a clearly drawn line, rejecting not just the command but the Commander's authority to give it.

This understanding of sin as transgression helps explain why David, after committing adultery with Bathsheba and arranging the death of her husband, cries out to God in Psalm 51:4:

David had clearly sinned against Bathsheba, against Uriah, against his own family, and against his entire kingdom. But he recognizes that at its core, his sin was transgression against God's law, a direct challenge to God's authority. Every sin, no matter who else it affects, is first and foremost a breaking of God's law, a rejection of His right to rule over us. This aspect of sin - its nature as transgression - helps us understand why we can't just balance out our sins with good deeds. Breaking a law isn't negated by following other laws. If someone runs a red light, they can't avoid a ticket by pointing out all the green lights they stopped at. When we transgress God's law, we're not just failing to meet a standard that we can make up for later - we're rebelling against the Lawgiver Himself. This is why Jesus had to die for our salvation. As sinners, we don't just need help reaching a standard; we need forgiveness for sin. We don't just need a boost up; we need pardon for our revolt against God's authority. This is why mere moral improvement could never solve our sin problem - what we need is amnesty for our rebellion against God.

Sin is Rebellion (Rejecting God’s Authority)

But sin goes deeper than just breaking rules. It’s rejecting the Rule-maker. It’s a rebellion against God's authority. When Moses confronted the Israelites about their disobedience, he didn't mince words:

Think about what had happened with Israel. God had demonstrated His power through ten mighty plagues. He had split the Red Sea. He was providing bread from heaven and water from rocks. He was guiding them with a pillar of cloud by day and fire by night. Yet despite all this visible evidence of God's power and provision, the people repeatedly refused to submit to His authority. It’s as if they were saying saying, “We know better than You.”

In the Garden of Eden, the real temptation wasn't just to eat forbidden fruit; it was to reject God's right to forbid anything. "You will be like God," the serpent promised, appealing to their desire to be their own authority.

We see this same rebellious heart throughout Scripture. In 1 Samuel 15:23, the prophet Samuel told Saul that:

He was pointing out that rejecting God's authority is essentially trying to enthrone ourselves in His place. It's spiritual treason. When Saul decided his way was better than God's explicit command, he wasn't just being disobedient - he was attempting to usurp God's right to rule. This is why even seemingly small sins are serious. Like that child crossing the line their parents told them not two, the issue, in addition to the specific command they’re refusing, is the challenge to parental authority in general.

And this rebellious nature of sin also explains why it’s so offensive to God. Imagine a kingdom where a group of citizens decides they don't want to follow the king's laws anymore. They're not just breaking specific rules; they're challenging the king's very right to reign. That's what we do when we sin - we're essentially saying, "God, I know better than You. I have the right to decide what's best for my life. Your wisdom, Your love, Your authority - I reject them all in favor of my own judgment."

It’s this aspect of sin that shows us why simple behavior modification isn’t enough. The problem isn’t solely our actions themselves; it’s our rebellious hearts that want to be our own gods. This is why true repentance involves more than just changing our behavior - it requires submitting ourselves back under God’s rightful authority and turning our hearts away from sin.

Inherited/Original Sin (Adam’s Impact on Humanity)

But here's where things get even more serious. Sin isn't just something we do - it's something we're born with. King David recognized this when he wrote,

David wasn’t suggesting that his birth or his mother’s pregnancy was sinful. Rather, he was acknowledging reality: before he had done anything right or wrong, before he had made any moral choices, sin was already present in his nature. Theologians call this "inherited sin" or "original sin." This concept helps us understand why even small children, who haven't yet learned right from wrong, still display selfishness, anger, and defiance. They don't need to be taught how to sin - it comes naturally. The apostle Paul explains this in Romans 5:12:

Think about this like a family inheritance, but in reverse. Usually, we inherit things after someone dies - money, property, heirlooms. But in this case, we inherited something from Adam while he was still living - his fallen nature. It's like a genetic condition that gets passed down through generations, except this condition affects our spiritual DNA. Just as we inherit physical traits from our ancestors without choosing them, we inherit this sinful nature from Adam without any choice in the matter.

Paul develops this idea further in Romans 5:19:

This verse reveals something crucial about inherited sin - it's not just about behavior; it's about our very identity. When Adam sinned, he didn't just do something wrong; he became something different. And that changed nature has been passed down to every human being since, except for Jesus Christ.

Understanding inherited sin helps explain several puzzling realities:

  1. First, it explains the universality of sin. Every culture, in every time period, has recognized that something is fundamentally wrong with human nature. We don't have to teach children to be selfish or lie - these tendencies emerge naturally. This is because we're not merely imitating Adam's sin; we're expressing the fallen nature we inherited from him.

  2. Second, it helps us understand why good intentions and moral effort aren't enough to solve our sin problem. You can't fix a genetic condition through behavior modification. Similarly, you can't overcome inherited sin just by trying harder to be good. The problem isn't just with what we do; it's with what we are.

  3. Third, it shows us why Jesus had to be born of a virgin. To break the chain of inherited sin, He couldn't inherit Adam's fallen nature. As the "last Adam" (1 Corinthians 15:45), Jesus needed to start fresh, without the spiritual genetic defect that affects all other humans.

This doctrine of inherited sin might seem unfair at first. After all, we didn't choose to inherit this condition. But understanding inherited sin actually gives us hope, because it points us to the solution.

Imputed Sin (Legal Guilt Passed Down)

This brings us to imputed sin. When Adam sinned in the Garden of Eden by eating from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, his act of disobedience produced two distinct but related effects that touch every human being: original sin (which we just discussed) and imputed sin. While original sin affects our nature - who we are - imputed sin affects our standing before God - our legal status.

To understand imputed sin, let's first understand what imputation means. In both legal and financial contexts, to impute something means to attribute or credit it to someone's account. When you deposit money in a bank, that amount is imputed - credited - to your account. Similarly, when we talk about imputed sin, we're saying that Adam's guilt is credited to our account.

The apostle Paul explains this profound reality in Romans:

Think about the implications here. Paul isn't just saying we inherit a tendency toward sin (that's original sin); he's saying we inherit the actual guilt of Adam's transgression. We are "counted as having sinned" in Adam. Just as a child might inherit a debt from their parent's estate, we inherit the liability of Adam's rebellion against God. This plays out in a couple of ways:

  • First, it affects our spiritual condition. Paul tells us in Ephesians 2:1-3 that we were "dead in our transgressions and sins" and "by nature deserving of wrath." This isn't just poetic language - it's describing our legal standing before God. We enter this world not as neutral parties who might eventually sin, but as those already under condemnation because of Adam's imputed guilt.

  • Second, it affects our physical reality. Romans 5:12 tells us that "death came to all people, because all sinned." Physical death entered human experience not just as a natural process but as a penalty for sin - first Adam's imputed sin, and then our own actual sins. This explains why even infants, who haven't committed personal sins, still experience death - they inherit both Adam's corrupt nature (original sin) and his guilt (imputed sin).

And this may sound unfair, but here's where God's redemptive plan reveals its brilliant symmetry. The same principle of imputation that brought condemnation becomes the means of our salvation. Paul explains this in 2 Corinthians:

Just as Adam's sin was imputed to us, Christ's righteousness can be imputed to believers. On the cross, our sin was imputed to Christ - He took our guilt upon Himself. And when we trust in Him, His perfect righteousness is imputed to us - we receive His righteous standing before God. This is what theologians call "double imputation" - our sin to Christ, His righteousness to us. And this is why Christ had to die on the cross for our sins. No amount of good works could overcome imputed guilt - we needed someone to take that guilt and give us a new standing before God. And the beautiful thing is that our hope isn't in overcoming our sinful nature through effort (dealing with original sin), but in receiving a new legal standing before God through Christ (dealing with imputed sin).

Think of it like this: A person might inherit both a genetic condition (like original sin) and a massive debt (like imputed sin) from their parents. Medicine might help manage the genetic condition, but it can't erase the debt. Only someone paying that debt in full could resolve that issue. That's what Christ did - He paid our debt of imputed sin and gives us His righteous standing before God.

Personal Sin (Daily Acts of Disobedience)

So having understood how sin affects us through Adam - both in our nature (original sin) and our standing before God (imputed sin) - we need to talk about the sins that we personally commit. These are our daily choices to disobey God. The apostle John addresses this reality head-on when writing:

Personal sin flows from our inherited sinful nature, but it involves our active participation. Think of it like this: We inherit a tendency toward certain diseases from our parents, but our lifestyle choices can either resist or accelerate those tendencies. Similarly, while we inherit a sinful nature from Adam, our personal sins involve our own choices and actions. And these personal sins take various forms. James helps us understand this progression in his letter, saying:

Notice the process: temptation appeals to our inherited sinful nature, we choose to embrace that temptation (personal sin), and that choice leads to death - separation from God's life-giving presence. This helps us understand why even believers continue to struggle with sin. While Christ's death deals with both original sin (giving us a new nature) and imputed sin (giving us a new standing), we still live in bodies affected by sin and face daily choices between obedience and disobedience.

The apostle Paul describes this ongoing struggle with devastating honesty in Romans 7:15 and 18:

This internal conflict between our new nature in Christ and our remaining sinful tendencies leads to personal sins. But here's a crucial difference between believers and unbelievers: While unbelievers sin from both nature and choice, believers sin despite their new nature, grieving the Holy Spirit within them (Ephesians 4:30).

This is why confessing our sins plays such a vital role in the Christian life. When John writes about confessing our sins, he's not talking about earning forgiveness - Christ's death has already secured that. Rather, confession is about maintaining fellowship with God and experiencing His ongoing cleansing in our lives. It's like a child who has disobeyed their parent - the relationship still exists, but fellowship is strained until the disobedience is acknowledged and addressed.

Understanding personal sin helps us grasp several important truths:

  1. First, it explains why behavioral modification alone never solves our sin problem. While we can and should resist temptation, our deeper need is for ongoing transformation through Christ.

  2. Second, it shows us why believers need both the finished work of Christ (dealing with original and imputed sin) and the ongoing work of the Holy Spirit (helping us resist personal sin).

  3. Third, it reminds us that while we're fully forgiven in Christ, we're not yet fully perfected. As John Newton famously said, "I am not what I ought to be, I am not what I want to be, I am not what I hope to be in another world; but still I am not what I once used to be, and by the grace of God I am what I am."

Understanding all these aspects of sin - transgression, rebellion, inherited/original sin, imputed sin, and personal sin - reveals why its effects run so deep and why God's solution had to be so comprehensive. Sin isn't just about bad choices; it's a condition that affects every part of who we are, influencing every choice we make and impacting every relationship we have. This understanding drives us to depend not on our own strength but on God's grace, provided through Christ's death and the Spirit's ongoing work in our lives.

The Effects of Sin

Original Design

When God created humans, He created us for something truly magnificent. In Genesis 1, we witness a profound shift in God's creative process. Throughout the chapter, God speaks creation into existence with the impersonal command "let there be." But when He reaches His crowning creative act - the formation of human life - something changes. The language becomes strikingly intimate and deliberate:

In Hebrew, this declaration of “Let us make man in our image, after our likeness” comes from Elohim (אֱלֹהִים), a plural name for God that appears over 2,550 times in Scripture. It’s a majestic name for the one true God that, while plural in its ending, is used throughout Scripture with singular verbs to emphasize His supreme sovereignty and infinite nature. When the ancient Jewish scholars translated this passage into Greek in the Septuagint, they captured this moment (“let us make man in our image, after our likeness”) with two carefully chosen terms: "εἰκόνα" (image) and "ὁμοίωσιν" (likeness). This dual description reveals something about our created purpose - we weren't just made to superficially resemble God, but to genuinely reflect and represent His nature and character on earth. This representation isn't about physical appearance. Rather, it encompasses our capacity for relationship, moral consciousness, creativity, rationality, and authority over creation. When God said "Let them have dominion," He was delegating a portion of His own sovereign rule to us. We were designed to be living, breathing representatives of God's character in the world - to exercise His wisdom in stewarding creation, to reflect His justice in our relationships, to demonstrate His love in our interactions, and to display His creativity in our work.

Think about that for a moment - as children we reflect our parent's features, mannerisms, and character. Well, humanity was meant to reflect and grow in God's attributes in a way that no other part of creation could. This wasn't just an honorary title or a vague spiritual concept - it was a real capacity and calling that was woven into the very fabric of our being. When God looked at humans, He intended to see something of Himself reflected back, like a mirror capturing and displaying His glory. But it goes even deeper than that.

Three Fundamental Relationships

The Bible shows us that humans were uniquely created for three fundamental relationships:

  1. with God

  2. with each other

  3. with creation itself

When God placed Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, we initially see all three relationships in perfect harmony. They walked with God in the cool of the day - that’s perfect vertical relationship with their Creator. They were naked and unashamed with each other - that’s perfect horizontal relationship between humans. And they were given authority to tend and care for the garden - that’s perfect outward relationship with creation. This threefold harmony was the target, the bull's-eye of our existence. It wasn't just about following rules or checking boxes - it was about living in perfect communion with God, experiencing completely authentic and vulnerable relationships with each other, and exercising wise stewardship over a creation that responded willingly to human care. And sin is everything that falls short of that target, and its effects ripple through all three of these fundamental relationships. It's like a stone thrown into a pond - the impact point might be in one area, but the ripples affect the entire surface. When we sin, we're not just breaking rules - we're fracturing the very relationships we were designed to thrive in. We're like a mirror that's supposed to reflect something breathtakingly beautiful, but it's cracked and distorted, showing only fragments and distortions of what it was meant to display.

Let me give you another way to understand this. Imagine you're sitting in a grand concert hall, listening to a world-class orchestra perform a magnificent symphony. Every instrument is perfectly tuned, every musician perfectly in time, every note exactly as the composer intended. That's what creation was meant to be - a perfect harmony of relationships all working together to create something beautiful that brings glory to the divine Composer. Now, when a violin string is out of tune, it's not just wrong - it's discordant. That single string doesn't just affect the violin it's on - it disrupts the entire orchestra. The violinist's section becomes discordant, which affects the entire string section, which impacts the whole orchestra. The beautiful harmony becomes cacophony. Sin is like that - it's not just individual wrong actions, it's a fundamental discord in the symphony of creation. Every sin, no matter how small it might seem, contributes to this cosmic cacophony, this disruption of the harmony that God intended.

And the thing about discord is that it tends to spread. Just as musicians might start adjusting their playing to try to accommodate an out-of-tune instrument (thereby making the problem worse), we humans often adjust our lives around our sinfulness rather than addressing the fundamental discord. We create coping mechanisms, justifications, and alternative, subjective, standards rather than seeking to fix the original issue itself. This is why understanding sin isn't just about understanding what we've done wrong - it's about understanding what we were made for in the first place. It's about recognizing that our deepest struggles, our most persistent problems, our most painful experiences often stem from this fundamental discord between what we were created to be and what we've become.

Consequences of Sin

The apostle Paul writes in Romans 6:23:

Most of us, when we hear the word “death,” think immediately of physical death - the stopping of a heart, the ending of brain activity. But in the Bible, death means something much deeper. At its core, biblical death means separation. Think about what happens in physical death: the soul separates from the body, the person separates from their loved ones, the individual separates from this physical world. Death, in its essence, is the severing of relationships. This kind of understanding transforms how we read Genesis. When God warned Adam and Eve that eating from the tree of knowledge of good and evil would result in death, He wasn’t solely talking about physical mortality. He was warning them about something far more devastating: a death that would ripple through every relationship they were created to enjoy. When they disobeyed, they didn’t die physically that day, but something else died - their perfect relationship with God, with each other, and with creation itself.

Let’s explore how this death (this separation) manifests in each of these fundamental relationships:

1. The Vertical Fracture

Our Relationship with God

The most immediate and devastating effect of sin is the fracturing of our relationship with God. Genesis 3:8 gives us a heartbreaking picture of this break:

Think about what’s happening here. Creation is hiding from its Creator. The children are running from their Father. Those made for intimate fellowship with God are now terrified of His presence. It’s like a toddler closing their eyes and thinking that no one can see them - both tragic and futile.

Imagine a plant violently uprooted from rich soil. At first, there’s not really much difference. The leaves remain green, the stem stands tall, perhaps even a flower continues to bloom. But something fundamental has changed - the plant has been disconnected from its source of life, water, and nutrients. Death isn’t just coming; it began the moment the roots left the soil.

This is what sin does to our relationship with God. We might continue functioning. We might even appear to thrive by worldly standards. But we’ve been disconnected from our source of life, wisdom, purpose, and truth. And the effects of this separation show up in various ways:

  • As existential emptiness: That persistent feeling that something’s missing, that nagging sense that life should mean more than it does.

  • Moral confusion: The inability to clearly discern right from wrong, like trying to read a compass near a powerful magnet.

  • Spiritual blindness: The incapacity to see and understand spiritual truth, like someone trying to appreciate a sunrise while wearing a blindfold.

  • Identity crisis: Forgetting whose image we bear, like an amnesia patient who can’t remember their family or who they are.

The apostle Paul describes the internal effects of this separation with devastating honesty in Romans 7:15-20:

Have you ever experienced this? That internal civil war between your aspirations and your actual behavior? This isn’t just moral weakness or lack of willpower - it’s a symptom of our broken relationship with God. When we’re disconnected from God, we’re cut off from the very source of goodness and truth. We’re like a lamp unplugged form the outlet, still intact but unable to fulfill its purpose of giving light.

2. The Horizontal Fracture

Our Relationships with Each Other

The breaking of our relationship with God immediately affects how we relate to each other. We see this pattern established in the very first moments after the fall when God confronts Adam:

Notice what happens in this single sentence - Adam manages to blame both Eve (“the woman…she gave me fruit of the tree”) as well as God Himself (“whom you gave to be with me”). The first human relationship, designed for perfect intimacy and partnership, fractures into blame and self-protection in a heartbeat.

This horizontal fracture manifests itself in three expanding circles of broken relationships, like ripples spreading out from a stone thrown into a pond:

  • Our relationships with ourselves: The first ripple affects our relationship with ourselves. The immediate consequence of sin was shame - Adam and Eve realized they were naked and tried to cover themselves. This shame wasn’t just about physical nakedness; it represented a new, painful self-consciousness. They became aware of themselves in a way they never had before, and that awareness was accompanied by shame, doubt, and internal conflict. We still carry this today. We struggle with self-hatred, with imposter syndrome, with the gap between who we are and who we think we should be.

  • Our intimate relationships: The second ripple affects our intimate relationships. The perfect vulnerability that existed between Adam and Eve - “they were both naked and were not ashamed” (Genesis 2:25) - is replaced by hiding, blame, and defensive posturing. This pattern has repeated itself in every human relationship since. Think about your own relationships. How many friendships have been affected by pride? How many marriages have been shattered by deceit? How many families have been torn apart by unresolved anger?

    Even our supposedly “private” sins affect our relationships in ways we don’t often recognize. For example, pornography is often considered a “victimless” private sin. Yet research shows that it fundamentally alters how people view and relate to others, objectifying them rather than seeing them as fellow image-bearers of God. Or consider something as subtle as envy - how it colors every interaction with the person we envy, making us unable to genuinely celebrate their successes or comfort them in their failures. Sin is like a pair of colored glasses - once we put them on, they tint everything we see, even if we forget we’re wearing them.

  • Our societal relationships: The third ripple extends to our broader social relationships, and this is where things can get particularly complex. And that’s because individual sins don’t stay individual - they become institutionalized into systems of injustice, cycles of violence, and structures of oppression. The prophets of the old testament understood this deeply. Amos thundered against those who “trample the head of the poor into the dust of the earth,” (Amos 2:7). Isaiah condemned those who “…decree iniquitous decrees, and the writers who keep writing oppression” (Isaiah 10:1b). These weren’t just individual acts of cruelty - they were systemic expressions of broken relationships.

    We see this today in racism, exploitation, human trafficking, and countless other forms of injustice. These aren’t just political problems, they are spiritual problems. They’re what happens when sin operates at a collective level, when broken people create broken systems that perpetuate brokenness. It’s like a computer virus that not only corrupts individual files, but spreads through the entire network, eventually becoming embedded in the operating system itself.

    The fracture even impacts how we form and maintain communities. Instead of reflecting God’s unity, we create barriers of hostility between each other. We form echo chambers that reinforce our biases, rather than have conversations with those who we may disagree with. The tower of Babel story in Genesis 11 illustrates this perfectly - humanity’s pride leads to division and scattering, the very opposite of God’s design for our communities.

What makes this horizontal fracture particularly insidious is how it compounds over time. Just as a small crack in the foundation of a home can eventual compromise the house itself, broken relationships often create patterns that echo through generations. We see this clearly demonstrated throughout the Bible.

Think about the pattern of deception that runs through Abraham’s family. Abraham lies about Sarah being his sister (Genesis 12:13; 20:2), his son Isaac later does the same thing with Rebekah (Genesis 26:7), and then Isaac’s son Jacob becomes known for his deception, first of his brother and then of his father (Genesis 27). Each generation, while responsible for their own choices, seems to struggle with the same pattern of sin. And this generational impact of sin is something God Himself addresses. In Exodus 20:5-6 when giving the Ten Commandments, He says:

This shows us that sin’s effects often ripple through families and communities in predictable patterns. However, it’s important to note that Scripture clarifies this doesn’t mean children are punished for their parents’ sins. As Ezekiel 18:20 says:

Each person is held accountable for their own actions. Rather, it’s recognizing that sin’s effects often ripple through families and communities in predictable patterns. And we see this today in how children often learn dysfunctional patterns from their parents, how communities continue cycles of violence, and how nations can perpetuate systems of injustice. But - and this is crucial - while these patterns are real, they’re not inevitable. Ezekiel 18:14-17 says this:

This is shows us that even if a father sins, his son can observe it, recognize its evil, and choose a different path. Every generation has the opportunity to break destructive patterns through repentance and the transforming power of God’s grace. And even in our fallen state, we see echoes of our original design. Our longing for genuine connection, our attempts to build community - these all reflect the image of God in us. We were made for relationship, and even in our broken state, we can't quite forget it. It's like a broken musical instrument - even if it can't play properly, its very structure tells you it was made for music.

3. The Outward Fracture

Our Relationship with Creation

Finally, let’s talk about how sin corrupts our relationship with creation itself. To really understand this, we need to revisit humanity’s original job description. In Genesis 1:28, God commands humanity to “have dominion” over creation. But this isn’t God giving us permission to exploit or misuse it. The Hebrew word for dominion here is וּרְדוּ (urdú, from רָדָה - radah), which carries the idea of governing wisely or acting as a responsible steward. Think of it as being entrusted with someone’s beloved pet—you don’t do whatever you want with it, but you care for it and make thoughtful, beneficial decisions. This responsibility becomes even clearer in Genesis 2:15, where God gives Adam another instruction:

Here’s where things get really interesting. The Hebrew words used in this verse are:

  • “to work it” - לְעָבְדָהּ (le-avdah) comes from the root verb עָבַד (abad)

  • “keep it” - וּלְשָׁמְרָהּ (ul'shamrah) comes from the root verb שָׁמַר (shamar), which means "to guard," "to keep," or "to protect:

These exact same verbs—עָבַד (abad) and שָׁמַר (shamar)—are later used in the Torah to describe the duties of priests in the tabernacle or temple. For example, in Numbers 3:7-8 and Numbers 8:26, the Levites are commanded to “serve” (עָבַד) and “guard” (שָׁמַר) the tabernacle, maintaining its sanctity and ensuring that it remains a place of God’s presence. Similarly, Ezekiel 44:14 describes the role of priests in serving and guarding sacred spaces, saying:

This connection isn’t accidental. Many biblical scholars view the Garden of Eden as the first sacred space where God’s presence dwelled, a proto-temple. By placing Adam in the garden with the instructions "to work it and to keep it," God was giving humanity a priestly role. We weren’t just supposed to be managers of creation—we were intended to treat creation as a sacred space, much like the temple, ensuring that it thrived in harmony with God’s design. Our purpose to “work” and “keep” creation goes beyond simply managing resources efficiently. Like priests who guard the temple, we were meant to protect, nurture, and respect creation as something holy and reflecting of God’s presence. This idea is echoed throughout Scripture, where creation is seen as a place that reveals God’s glory (Psalm 19:1) and where humans are described as a “kingdom of priests” (Exodus 19:6).

But sin broke this relationship, too. Paul talks about this in Romans 8:22, saying:

Think about that image for just a moment - creation groaning like a woman in labor. If you’ve ever been around someone giving birth or talked to someone who has about it, you know that labor pains are intense, real suffering. But - and this is crucial - they’re pain with a purpose. They’re leading somewhere. Paul’s saying that creation is in this kind of pain right now - real suffering, but suffering that’s pointing toward new life.

This plays out in several ways in our world:

  1. Our relationship with the earth itself. Instead of being careful stewards, we often act more like careless thieves. Acts like deforestation, polluted water sources, destroyed habitats, extinct species. God told Adam after sin entered the picture that the ground itself would now product “thorns and thistles,” (Genesis 3:18). It’s like the earth itself is pushing back against sin.

  2. The natural order. Eden was designed to be a place of perfect harmony—no predators, no prey, and no fear. In Genesis 1:29-30, both humans and animals were originally given plants for food, suggesting a world without predation or violence. But after the Fall, everything changed. Nature became what Tennyson described as “red in tooth and claw” (Tennyson, In Memoriam A.H.H., Canto 56). We now experience natural disasters, disease, decay, and death—things that were never part of God’s original design. (While Genesis 1:29-30 implies a peaceful, non-violent creation, some interpret the original state differently, seeing animal death as a natural part of creation but human death as the consequence of sin. However, the overall biblical narrative emphasizes that violence and corruption within creation result from the Fall.)

    The prophet Isaiah gives us a glimpse of what creation was meant to be when he describes a future restoration, saying:

    The wolf shall dwell with the lamb, and the leopard shall lie down with the young goat, and the calf and the lion and the fattened calf together; and a little child shall lead them. The cow and the bear shall graze; their young shall lie down together; and the lion shall eat straw like the ox. The nursing child shall play over the hole of the cobra, and the weaned child shall put his hand on the adder's den. They shall not hurt or destroy in all my holy mountain; for the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the Lord as the waters cover the sea.” - Isaiah 11:6-9 (ESV, emphasis added).

    This vision of peace points directly back to Eden’s original harmony, where violence and danger didn’t exist. Instead, these destructive aspects of nature arose as a consequence of sin, as described in Genesis 3:17-19 when the ground is cursed, and in Romans 8:20-22. Tennyson’s observation captures the harsh reality of a post-Fall world, but the Bible attributes this brokenness to the curse described in Genesis 3:17-19, where the ground itself rebels against humanity, and in Romans 8:22, where creation groans in anticipation of its restoration. But God’s blueprint hasn’t been abandoned - Isaiah’s prophecy reminds us that the future holds a restoration of creation to its intended place, where nature no longer reflects corruption, but rather it reflects God’s perfect order.

  3. Our way of seeing the natural world has been twisted. Instead of viewing creation as God’s temple that we’re supposed “to work it” (לְעָבְדָהּ) and “keep it” (וּלְשָׁמְרָהּ), we often just see it as a resource to use up. It’s like the difference between being given responsibility for a set of fine china and being handed a stack of disposable plates. When we do try to protect nature, it’s usually because we’re scared of what will happen if we don’t, not because we understand our actual role as treating creation as God’s temple. But what I find incredible in all of this, is that even in its broken state, creation is still doing its main job of glorifying God. As Psalm 19 puts it, "The heavens declare the glory of God, and the sky above proclaims his handiwork." In fact, Paul tells us that creation's groaning isn't just pain - it's anticipation. Like a mother in labor knows there's a baby coming, creation knows there's restoration coming.

    This is why taking care of creation isn't just about political debates or saving the planet. That’s surface-level compared to the true meaning. It's about getting back to our original calling as treating creation as God’s temple. All of this helps us understand why what Jesus did had to be so comprehensive. Sin didn't just mess up our individual relationship with God - it broke everything. Through Christ's death on the cross, God first reconciles us to Himself (Colossians 1:22), and through that reconciliation, He begins the process of restoring all that sin has broken. As Paul describes in Romans 8:19-21, creation itself eagerly awaits this final restoration that will come when God's children are fully revealed in glory.

Common Misconceptions About Sin

After spending all this time understanding what sin really is - how it breaks our relationships with God, each other, and creation - we need to talk about some ideas that often trip us up. I've found that these misunderstandings don't just affect how we think about sin; they affect how we approach God and how we handle the struggles in our daily lives.

It's kind of like when we're dealing with any problem in life - if we don't really understand what we're dealing with, our solutions probably won't work. Let's look at some of these misconceptions together and see what the Bible actually tells us about them.

"Some Sins Aren't Really That Bad"

Perhaps the most prevalent misconception that people have about sin is the idea that some sins are relatively harmless - what we might call "little white lies" or "harmless sins." “What's the harm in a little white lie? Nobody's getting hurt!" We tend to rank sins in our minds, putting some in the "really bad" category and others in the "not such a big deal" box.

Yet sin is still sin.

But here's what James tells us about this kind of thinking:

Let me give you an example that helped me understand this better. Imagine you're hanging a family photo on your wall. If one corner is just a tiny bit off, what happens? The whole picture looks crooked, right? It doesn't matter if it's off by a little or a lot - crooked is crooked. You can't look at that frame and say, "Well, it's only a little crooked, so it's basically straight!"

Similarly, any sin, no matter how small it might seem to us, represents a break in our alignment with God's character. Now, I'm not saying all sins have the same consequences in our daily lives - obviously, murder causes more immediate harm than a white lie. But when it comes to our relationship with God, any sin creates distance between us and Him. This might sound harsh at first, but understanding this truth actually leads us to appreciate God's grace even more. When Jesus died on the cross, He paid for all of it - the "big" sins and the "small" ones. God's grace is so comprehensive that Jesus said every kind of sin and blasphemy can be forgiven:

The only exception Jesus mentioned was what He called "blasphemy against the Spirit" - a very specific historical situation where the Pharisees, despite witnessing Jesus perform miracles through the Holy Spirit's power, deliberately attributed that power to demons. They had the fullest possible evidence of God's work right in front of them, yet they willfully rejected it. Or put more simply, the only unforgivable sin today is the state of continued unbelief.

But for anyone who comes to God in genuine repentance, His grace covers everything.

"Good Deeds Can Offset Sin"

Another common idea I hear about sin goes something like this: "Well, sure, I've done some bad things, but I've done a lot of good too. I’m basically a good person so I’ll go to heaven, right?" I call this the "balance sheet" view - as if God is some kind of divine accountant, tallying up our good deeds in one column and our sins in another, and here we are hoping everything balances out in the end.

But there’s two issues with this kind of thought:

The Nature of Sin

But remember what we learned about the nature of sin - it's not just about actions but about relationship. If I'm unfaithful to my wife, can erase what I did completely by just doing more dishes or buying her some flowers? Of course not. The unfaithfulness happened, and doing 1,000 loads of laundry or spending a ton of money on gifts doesn’t go back in time and undo the action of being unfaithful.

Imputed Sin

But even if it did undo it, somehow (which it doesn’t) - remember what we learned about imputed sin? We're not just dealing with our own individual sins - we've inherited Adam's guilt. It's like being born into a family that has more debt than there is money or resources available on the planet. No matter how many extra jobs you work or how frugally you live, you can't ever earn enough to pay off that kind of debt. The problem is simply too big for our good works to solve. That's why Paul emphasizes in Ephesians 2:8-9:

Notice how Paul says this is "not your own doing" - it's a gift. Think about how gifts work. If you try to pay for a gift, it's not a gift anymore, is it? If your friend gives you a birthday present and you immediately pull out your wallet to reimburse them, you've just turned their gift into a transaction. That's not what they wanted!

This doesn't mean good works don't matter - they absolutely do! In fact, the very next verse, Ephesians 2:10, tells us:

But here's the crucial difference: good works are the result of salvation, not the cause of it. They're the fruit, not the root. When we truly understand what God has done for us through Christ, good works flow naturally out of gratitude and love, not out of an attempt to earn God's favor. This is incredibly liberating when we really grasp it. We don't have to constantly wonder if we've done enough good to outweigh our bad. We don't have to live under the crushing weight of trying to earn God's love. Instead, we can rest in what Christ has already done for us, and let our good works flow from a heart of gratitude rather than obligation.

"Sin Is Just About Breaking Rules"

This third misconception might be the most dangerous of all, because it fundamentally misunderstands both God's character and His purpose for us. Many people think of sin as simply violating a divine rulebook, as if God were some cosmic police officer hiding behind a celestial billboard, radar gun in hand, just waiting to catch us doing something wrong. Think about parents and their children for a moment. Good parents don't make rules just because they enjoy controlling their kids, right? When a parent tells their toddler not to touch a hot stove, they're not trying to spoil their fun - they're protecting them because they love them. When they establish bedtimes, it's not to ruin their evening - it's because they understand their child's need for rest and routine. The rules flow from the relationship and the parent's deep desire for their child's wellbeing.

It's the same way with God, but even more so. The rules, or law, in Scripture serve an important purpose - they show us where we're missing the mark. But they're not the mark itself. Think of them like warning signs on a road. The signs aren't the destination; they're guides to keep us safe on the journey toward the destination. The destination - the mark we're actually aiming for - is relationship with God. This helps us understand why Jesus said the greatest commandment is to:

Notice He didn't say the greatest commandment was to follow all the rules perfectly. The rules exist to protect and guide that love relationship, not to replace it.

We see this truth illustrated beautifully in the Garden of Eden. Before there was any law given, before there were any rules about sacrifices or ceremonies or religious observances, there was relationship. Adam and Eve walked with God in the cool of the day. The one command they received - not to eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil - wasn't about God restricting their freedom. It was about maintaining the trust in their relationship with Him.

When we reduce sin to just breaking rules, we turn God into something He's not - a distant lawgiver rather than a loving Father. Second, we miss the real tragedy of sin - that it breaks the relationship God designed us to enjoy with Him, with each other, and with creation itself. Which hurts more - when your child breaks a house rule, or when they look you in the eye and say "I don't trust you"? The broken rule might be frustrating, but the broken trust cuts to the heart. That's what sin really is - a break in trust, a fracture in relationship, a decision to go our own way rather than walking with God.

God's Response to Sin

After everything we've learned about sin - how it's not just breaking rules but breaking relationships, how it affects not just our actions but our very nature - we have to ask: How does God respond to all of this?

God’s Holiness Demands Justice

First, we need to understand that God's holiness demands justice. Throughout Scripture, we see that God cannot simply pretend sin didn't happen or sweep it under the cosmic rug. His holiness - His absolute moral perfection - requires that sin be addressed. The prophet Habakkuk captures this when he says:

Think about a perfectly clean room. Even a thing out of place stands out glaringly. God's holiness is like that, but infinitely more pure. Sin cannot exist in His presence - not because He's being difficult, but because holiness and sin are fundamentally incompatible, like light and darkness.

But the same holiness that demands justice is paired with a love so profound it provides the solution. The apostle John captures this beautiful paradox:

Now, "propitiation" isn't a word we use every day, but it's crucial to understand. It means a sacrifice that fully satisfies justice. Imagine owing a debt you could never repay, and someone steps in to pay it completely. That would be incredible right? But imagine that they then do even more than that, they also make you a co-heir of their entire fortune. That's what Christ does for us on the cross. Through Christ's death on the cross, God does something remarkable - He maintains His perfect holiness while extending mercy to sinners. Christ takes our imputed guilt and gives us His imputed righteousness. He bears the punishment our sins deserved, satisfying divine justice, while offering us forgiveness and restoration.

There's a beautiful Japanese art form called kintsugi that helps us understand what God does with our brokenness. When precious pottery breaks, instead of throwing it away or trying to hide the cracks, artists repair it with gold. The result is something more beautiful than the original - the gold-filled cracks tell a story of brokenness and restoration.

This is what God does with our broken relationships. Through Christ, we're not just patched up - we're restored and made more beautiful than before. The restoration touches every relationship sin has broken:

  • We're reconciled to God (2 Corinthians 5:18)

  • Our human relationships can experience healing (Ephesians 2:14)

  • Even creation itself will be restored (Romans 8:19-21)

The scars are transformed from marks of sin into testimonies of grace. Our brokenness, touched by God’s grace, becomes part of our testimony as children of God. This is why the gospel isn’t just good advice - it’s good news. It’s not about what we must do to fix ourselves; it’s about what God has done to restore us. He doesn’t just forgive us; He transforms us. He doesn’t just save us from sin; He saves us fro relationship with Him. And in the end, everything that sin broke, God will make new - and even more beautiful than before.

Putting It Into Perspective: How Do We Live This Out?

Understanding what sin is, the nature of sin, the effects of sin, and God’s response to sin is crucial, but we need to take this an apply it to daily life. Let’s look at two key aspects of dealing with sin in a practical manner: how to recognize it, and how to respond when we do.

Recognizing Sin in Our Lives

Think of recognizing sin like learning something new - at first, you might miss things, but over time you get better at it. God gives us three main ways to help us recognize sin in our lives:

1. Self-Examination

First, we need regular self-examination. King David shows us what this looks like when he prays:

It’s like doing regular health check-ups. Just as you might notice something’s not quite right with you body and get it checked out, we need to pay attention to our spiritual health as well. Ask yourself: “Where am I pushing back against what God wants? Have I let bitterness creep into my relationships? Am I treating other’s the way God intended?"

2. Holy Spirit’s Help in Recognizing Sin

Second, we have the Holy Spirit’s help in recognizing sin. Jesus promised the Spirit would help us understand when we’re off track. But there’s a big difference between the Holy Spirit’s conviction and what we might call condemnation. When a loving parent corrects their child, they’re specific about what needs to change and they help their child grow. That’s how the Holy Spirit works.

3. The Bible as Our Guide

Third, we have the Bible as our guide. God’s Word helps us understand what sin really is, rather than just going by what our culture or feelings tell us. It’s like having a reliable map instead of just guessing which way to go, or randomly following someone else when you have no idea if they actually even know where they’re going.

What to Do When We Spot Sin

Okay, so what do we do when we recognize sin in our lives?

1. Confession

First comes honesty with God about our sin - what the Bible calls “confession.” Now, this is really important to understand: when we talk about confession, we’re not talking about any sort of religious ritual or system where we need another person or priest to mediate between us and God. The Bible is clear in this - through Christ, every believer is part of what Peter calls a “royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9). This means that we can talk directly to God ourselves.

In the Old Testament, people had to go through priests to approach God. The priests were like spiritual middle-men, offering sacrifices on behalf of the people. But when Jesus died on the cross and established the New Covenant, the temple veil tore in two, symbolizing that the wall between God and humanity had been destroyed. Now, because of Jesus’ sacrifice, we can approach God’s throne boldly ourselves (Hebrews 4:16). We don’t need any human mediator because Jesus is our great High Priest (Hebrews 4:14-15), and He’s the only mediator that we need between us and God (1 Timothy 2:5).

So what does biblical confession look like? It’s about being direct and honest with God about our sin. When David sinned, he cried out directly to God, “Against you, you only, have I sinned and done what is evil in your sight” (Psalm 51:4). Like we mentioned at the beginning of this article, 1 John 1:9 tells us:

Notice that there’s no middle-man here - there’s no human priest that we’re confessing to. That’s because the concept of confession of sin to a human priest as a mediator between us and God isn’t taught in the Bible. Rather, it’s just us being honest with God about our sin.

2. Repentance

Repentance is what should flow naturally from true confession to God. It’s like making a U-turn when you realize you’re driving the wrong way. You don’t just think to yourself, “I’m going the wrong way. This isn’t right. Oh well!” And then keep on driving in the wrong direction. You turn around and start going the correct way instead. Real repentance means both an acknowledgement of going the wrong direction (sin) and a change in direction away from it (the U-turn).

3. Accepting God’s Forgiveness

Then comes something surprisingly hard - accepting God’s forgiveness. You know how sometimes when someone forgives you, you still feel guilty and keep apologizing? Many of us do the same thing with God. But remember what we learned about Christ’s righteousness being given to us? Imputed to us? When God forgives us, it’s complete.

4. Breaking the Pattern of Sin

Next, we need to work on breaking those patterns of sin in our lives. This isn’t something that we can do through sheer willpower alone (remember what we learned about original/inherited sin?), but God gives us His Spirit to help us. And thank God for that! This might mean identifying what triggers certain sins, finding people who can hold us accountable, and building new, healthy habits to replace the harmful ones.

5. Restoration

And finally, there’s restoration - making things right where we can. This might mean working to rebuild trust in relationships that we’ve damaged or making amends for wrongs we’ve done. Think of it like physical therapy after an injury - healing has happened, but getting back to full strength takes time and effort.

But here’s what’s important to remember through all of this: none of this is about earning God’s love - we already have that in Christ. This is about living as who we really are - God’s beloved children. It’s like learning to walk - we might stumble, but our Father is right there, propping us back up, and helping us to grow stronger with each step.

Wrapping Up

If you’ve made it this far - wow. Thank you. We’ve covered a lot of ground today in talking about sin. We’e seen that it’s far more than just breaking rules - but that it’s a fundamental fracturing of relationships that affects every part of our lives. From Adam’s first act of rebellion, sin has created ripples that touch everything: our relationship with God, our connections with each other, and even our interaction with creation itself. And if this sounds overwhelming - well, it should be.

Sin is the most serious problem that we face.

There is no amount of education, technology, or human effort that can solve it. We can’t earn our way into heaven by balancing our sins with good deeds, simply trying harder to be better, or pretending that it doesn’t matter. But through Christ’s death and resurrection, God doesn’t just forgive our sins, He provides a solution that addresses every single aspect of sin’s damage. He takes our imputed guilt and gives us Christ’s righteousness. He takes our inherited sinful nature and gives us a new one. He provides His Spirit to help us recognize and resist personal sin.

And this doesn’t mean that our lives will be perfect - we’ll continue to struggle with sin until Christ returns. But it does mean that we’re not fighting alone, and the final outcome is certain. One day, every relationship that sin has broken will be fully restored. As John puts it in Revelation 21:5, God will “make all things new.”

Next Week

Next week, we’ll be looking at another crucial question: “How can I be certain that I’ve not committed the unforgivable sin?” Until then, I encourage you to take what we’ve learned today and start putting it into practice. Begin developing those habits of self-examination, learn to recognize the Spirit’s conviction, and remember - when you do sin, you can come directly to God for forgiveness because of what Christ has done.

Because understanding sin isn’t about feeling hopeless - it’s about recognizing our need for a Savior and appreciating the magnificent way God has provided one in Jesus Christ.

See this content in the original post

See this form in the original post